Bishop at the Lake (Greeley) - Book Reviews

Book Reviews
In Greeley's winning sixth Blackie Ryan novel (after 2006's The Bishop in the Old Neighborhood), Ryan's boss, the archbishop of Chicago, sends Ryan to check up on Malachi Howard-Nolan, a fellow priest who's jockeying for a prestigious appointment. Blackie heads out to the compound where Nolan's extended family has gathered for a reunion and discovers that matters are both simpler and more complex than he'd imagined. Nolan turns out to be obnoxious and ambitious, but also lazy and incompetent, so his ecclesiastical aspirations aren't likely to come to much. When Nolan suffers a life-threatening attack of hornets, Blackie suspects someone in his rich, nutty family wishes him ill. There's also romance afoot: Blackie's strapping nephew finds himself attracted to Nolan's charming niece. A few chapters narrated by the nephew jar, but strong character development, snappy dialogue and a multilayered plot make this one of the better entries in the series.
Publishers Weekly


Blackie Ryan returns in another predictable but fun Chicago-based whodunit featuring the usual amalgamation of stereotypical Irish-American characters.... [A] puzzling locked-room mystery.... Nothing new here, but most Greeley fans won't want or expect anything beyond this comfortably familiar plot. —Margaret Flanagan
Booklist


Bishop Blackie confronts another locked-room mystery, this one with hornets. Chicago's coolest cleric is dispatched to posh Grand Beach, enclave of the rich and contentious Nolan clan, under orders to sniff around. The recent, possibly sneaky behavior of Archbishop Malachi Nolan, son of the progenitor, has piqued the interest of Sean Cardinal Cronin, Blackie's boss. Ever alert to the surge of others' ambition, the Cardinal is concerned about the precise shape of Malachi's. Opportunities for sniffing, however, vanish when Malachi is ferociously attacked. His whole family knows Malachi's unfortunate history with hornets, whose bites have led to severe allergic reactions. Someone has managed to introduce and unleash a swarm of them into the locked room in question, and the result is nearly lethal. Is it a case of attempted murder? Is the Pope Catholic? "Well, you better solve that locked-room mystery, or your perfect record will be ruined," the Cardinal enjoins Blackie, who solves it, of course—as will many, many readers, since it's not all that mysterious. Or interesting. As for the internecine war among the Nolans, here too the author has done better. As usual, Father Greeley serves up heaping helpings of the Irish goo (Irish Linen, etc.) that his audience has always found yummy.
Kirkus Reviews